From the raw materials list to the actual carbon footprint: In this interview, Dr Christian Reisinger explains why Scope 3 is more than just a reporting issue - and how companies are making their supply chains climate-ready with structure, prioritization and the ESG software Substain. With specific tips on data quality, supplier engagement and efficient implementation.
Scope 3 emissions: Why are they so central - and at the same time so elusive?
Dr. Christian Reisinger:
Scope 3 emissions are all CO₂ emissions that occur upstream or downstream along the value chain - i.e. outside a company's direct sphere of influence. These include, for example, emissions from purchased raw materials, business travel, logistics or even the use and disposal of the company's own products. Scope 1, on the other hand, describes emissions from the company's own sources, e.g. from heating systems or vehicle fleets. Scope 2 includes indirect emissions from purchased energy - such as electricity or district heating.
While companies can usually document Scope 1 and 2 - i.e. direct emissions and purchased energy - relatively well, Scope 3 data is often opaque. They require an intensive examination of the company's own supply chain and the exact structure of purchasing. In practice, Scope 3, especially for manufacturing companies, is often by far the largest share of a company's emissions - sometimes over 80%. At the same time, it is the most difficult to record because much of the data lies outside the company's own system boundaries. This is precisely why Scope 3 is increasingly coming into focus: without it, every carbon footprint remains incomplete - and every reduction strategy half-hearted.
"The biggest hurdle is often not the calculation itself, but the question: What do I actually have to record? And where do I get reliable data for this?"
Many companies are surprised when they realize, for example, that the electricity consumption of their products in the use phase has to be included in their own emissions. Other challenges lie in the data itself: Purchasing lists are often unstructured, use inconsistent units (e.g. pieces, kg, pallets) and contain free text descriptions that are hardly usable for CO₂ balancing.
How do you get started? What should companies look out for when structuring Scope 3 reporting?
Dr. Reisinger:
The trick is to take a structured and pragmatic approach. After all, Scope 3 is not a one-off exercise, but a continuous learning and improvement process. The following approach has proven effective for getting started:
- Impact analysis: Which of the 15 Scope 3 categories are relevant at all?
- Check data sources: What quantity or financial data is already available? Which of these are usable?
- Identify suppliers: Who are my main emitters? Which 20% of suppliers account for 80% of emissions?
- Differentiate between data qualities: The four levels according to the GHG protocol help to realistically classify and specifically improve existing data.
Data quality levels according to the GHG protocol:
- Stage 1: Primary data from the supplier
- Stage 2: Secondary data from scientific databases
- Level 3 & 4: Spend-based data on a euro basis or Estimates/projections
In reality, most companies have less than 5% of scope 3 data at level 1. The remaining 95% must be carefully derived - for example using weight data and standardized emission factors, such as those already stored in Substain. Spend-based methods are possible, but are less accurate and methodologically vulnerable.
Which Scope 3 categories are particularly worthwhile when starting out - and what should you look out for?
Dr. Reisinger:
Not all categories are equally relevant - also because not all of them can be influenced equally well. We know from consulting experience and software projects: The greatest leverage almost always lies in purchased goods and services (category 3.1). Together with capital goods and upstream logistics, this area often forms the focus of the carbon footprint.
Typical mistakes that we see in projects:
- Raw materials are not classified by material class or application
- Quantities are available in different units (kg, m², pallets, etc.)
- Suppliers are not clearly assigned or exist multiple times
- Transportation services are overlooked if they are "included in the price"
"When it comes to digitalization, many purchasing departments think of ordering processes - but not of CO₂ data. Yet this is where the greatest opportunity lies to get off to a methodically clean start."
It is also important to recognize where suppliers can contribute - and where they cannot: business travel or product use, for example, are internal company issues. But raw materials, machinery and transportation are classic supplier areas. This is where a targeted and professional approach should be taken.
How does Substain help with concrete implementation - especially with supplier surveys?
Dr. Reisinger:
Scope 3 balancing often fails due to the effort involved. Anyone who contacts 100 suppliers manually, checks data, manages documents - loses months. Substain solves precisely this problem with the integrated Supplier Portal.
This is how Substain supports supplier integration:
- Supplier creation and management: centralized, structured, also via Excel import or API
- Standardized questionnaires: for ESG master data, product carbon footprints, EUDR or CSRD-relevant topics
- Automated communication: dispatch including reminder function and deadline tracking
- AI-based preliminary check: check for completeness, system limits, plausibility of values
- Direct integration: verified values automatically flow into the CO₂ balance sheet
Substain also supports communication: if suppliers are not yet able to provide primary data, this can be documented in the tool. Companies can then offer these suppliers training or discounted access to the Substain platform, for example.
"We say: challenge and encourage. Those who provide data are preferred - and those who need help get support."
And why is all this worthwhile - beyond regulation and the fulfillment of duties?
Dr. Reisinger:
Of course, CSRD, ESRS and EUDR are strong drivers. But there are also good reasons to tackle Scope 3 in your own interest:
- Efficiency and relief: If you receive primary data from the supplier, you have to research and justify fewer emission factors yourself - this saves time and reduces the amount of checking required.
- Better climate strategies: Real data enables realistic reduction paths - not just estimates.
- Customer loyalty and tenders: Those who can provide credible CO₂ data have a competitive advantage.
- Synergy effects: Supplier data on ESG, CO₂, EUDR, human rights, certificates, etc. can be bundled and maintained holistically.
- Continuous improvement: Companies can track and increase their primary data share annually - and make measurable improvements.
"Scope 3 data is not a bureaucratic burden - it is the basis for better decisions. Those who understand and use it become more resilient, more transparent and more attractive - for customers, partners and investors."
Conclusion
Scope 3 is challenging - but solvable. With the right mindset, clear processes and suitable software such as Substain, regulatory pressure can be turned into real room for maneuver. For more transparency, better reduction strategies - and for a climate-friendly supply chain.
About Substain
Substain is the ideal software solution for companies that want to organize ESG management efficiently and comprehensively. Based on the "single source of truth" principle, Substain enables centralized collection, analysis and reporting of all ESG data - simple, transparent and compliant with legal requirements. With Substain, you benefit from maximum flexibility, customizability and an intuitive dashboard that facilitates data-based decisions. Developed specifically for the requirements of SMEs, Substain helps companies to confidently meet regulatory requirements, effectively implement sustainable strategies and secure their long-term competitiveness.